‘Pertandingan Penghujahan Mahkamah 2025″ was organised jointly by the Bar Council, UiTM and Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka on 11-12 January at UiTM Shah Alam. Organised by the BM Committee of BC chaired by senior lawyer Mr Salehuddin and assisted by Mr Khairul Naim.Two finals took place viz. university students category and young lawyers category. I was invited to sit in the panel of judges for the young lawyers category with a High Court Judge and a Pakar Bahasa from DBP. It was an appeal from a summary judgment application that was dismissed. It was indeed wonderful to observe young lawyers showing their ability, passion and tenacity in presenting their arguments – in the national language without flaw . Personally, sitting on the other side makes one understand what goes in the judges mind and why certain remarks or response were made at certain times during proceedings. A learning trip indeed.Young lawyers category was won by the Terengganu team who as respondent came with a ‘nuclear point’ to blow up the Perak team’s appeal. IIUM won the university category, and guess what, also took the 2nd place.

Attended the Opening of the Legal Year (OLY) 2025 yesterday at the Putrajaya International Convention Centre. The event saw a gathering of judges, lawyers and members of AGC to mark the start of the year for the legal fraternity and for the fraternity to reaffirm their commitment to justice, constitutional supremacy, and the independence of the judiciary. In her speech, Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun noted that this is her last OLY and reflected on her tenure since 2018. She emphasized the judiciary’s commitment to upholding the Federal Constitution as the supreme law of the land, constitutional milestones under her term, and the role of judges. The highlight of her speech was the reminder on the importance of independence of the judiciary and the selection process of judges. The Chief Justice underscored the importance of an independent judicial appointments process, cautioning against any interference that could undermine public confidence in the judiciary and the need for the Executive headed by the Prime Minister to live up to it’s commitment for an independent judiciary and non-interference in judicial appointments. President of the Malaysian Bar Mohamad Ezri Abdul Wahab spoke on the role of the Bar, lack of consultation with the Bar when enacting new laws despite the Bar’s unique expertise on the matter, need for transparency in judicial appointment process, independence of judiciary, prison reform and restorative justice. Attorney General Dato’ Mohd Dusuki bin Mokhtar outlined the AGC’s key achievements in 2024, including the implementation of online systems like e-Daftar and e-Rep to enhance efficiency in criminal case management. He also emphasized the AGC’s commitment to continuous improvement and cooperation with the judiciary and the Bar. OLY serves to refresh our commitment as members of the administration of justice, and of course a chance to reconnect with old friends, and connecting with new friends.

Elevation proceedings is a proud tradition of the Bar, held to celebrate and felicitate the appointment of a new judge as the King’s judges. In Malaysia it is usually held when a Judicial Commissioner is appointed (elevated) as judge or when a person is appointed directly. It starts with formal proceedings in open court with felicitations by the State Bar, Bar Council and then AGC. Generally, to introduce the new judge to the lawyers, congratulate him/her, express the Bar’s expectation and then offer some words of advice to the new judge. The Judge reciprocates with his appreciation of the Bar, and states his expectations in his court from the Bar. This then followed by refreshments. Currently, sadly, only a handful state bars are organising this, including the Johore Bar. Yesterday, the ceremony commenced with Chairman Mr Fadhil offering his introduction and felicitations welcoming His Lordship to the Bench , followed by my felicitations on behalf of the Malaysian Bar and Tuan Muhammad Azzam representing the AGC. Justice Suria Kumar reciprocated with a speech on his background and shared his experience , thoughts and his expectations of the Bar. He also expressed his deep appreciation to his family and friends especially senior members who had guided him in his 30 years of practice. It was great to see many lawyers attending this appreciating the proceedings. So, what is expected of a judge? Socrates: “Four things belong to a judge: to listen courteously, to answer wisely, to consider soberly and to decide impartially”. Lord Neuberger on the basic qualities for a judge when running a trial: “grip, authority, politeness, fairness, an ability to simplify and an ability to express yourself.” Congratulations, Judge.

Good topics for discussion and well attended. Well done to the BC Small Firms Practice Committee and the Chairs Hasnifalina Hasanudin and Fauzana Ismail . Looking forward to the next edition of the Convention.