loader image

Dismissal for poor performance.


It is not uncommon for employers to deploy the grounds of ‘poor performance’ as means of dismissal of employee.

This, is an abuse of employer’s rights and managerial prerogative. The Industrial Court will intervene and struck down such dismissals.

The following general guidelines apply when determining the bona fide of dismissals on grounds of poor performance:

1. Employer must prove that the employee was warned of his poor performance.

2. Employee was accorded sufficient opportunity to improve, and;

3. Despite the above, the employee failed to sufficiently improve his performance.

Employers to be mindful that:

1. Poor performance is not misconduct.

2. Prior warnings of poor performance must be given.

3. Employer must undertake rehabilitative measures to assist underperforming employees.

4. If the employee is placed on Performance Improvement Plan (PIP), the PIP must be in good faith, clear, reasonable and complied with closely.

5. Where targets are set for underperforming employees, the target must be reasonable. Unreasonable targets can be struck down as unfair labour practice.

6. Employees must be given sufficient time, guidance and opportunity to improve.

See
– Ireka Construction Berhad v. Chantiravathan a/l Subramaniam James [1995] 2 ILR 11

– Lee Hsin Ying v. Sleekflow Technologies Sdn Bhd – Award No. 55 of 2026

Related

Election to Bar Council 2027/2028

ELECTION TO BAR COUNCIL 2027/2028 It is November. The annual election for 16 (out of 42) members of the Bar Council for incoming term 2027/2028 is taking place. The Bar Council manages affairs of...

Objection at Long Call and Social Media Postings: A Cautionary Tale for Pupils

Objection at Long Call and Socmed postings In a very recent long call, an objection was raised by the former employer of the petitioner that the petitioner was not a fit and proper person to be called...

Sijil Annual 2027: Time to Start Working on the Application

Time to start working on the application. The Malaysian Bar has announced: “Apply for your Sijil Annual 2027 now. Please go to mybar.my/SAPC2027 to download the complete version of Circular No...

Contact Detail

Follow Us

Newsletter

You have been successfully Subscribed! Ops! Something went wrong, please try again.

R. Jayabalan ©  | All Rights Reserved